Posts Tagged vegetarianism
Title: Eating Animals
Author: Jonathan Safran Foer
Pages: 352 (hardcover)
Release Date: November 2, 2009
Publisher: Little, Brown and Company
Review source: Hachette Book Group
As my son began life and I began this book, it seemed that almost everything he did revolved around eating. He was nursing, or sleeping after nursing, or getting cranky before nursing, or getting rid of the milk he had just nursed. As I finish this book, he is able to carry on quite sophisticated conversations, and increasingly the food he eats is digested together with the stories we tell. Feeding my child is not like feeding myself: it matters more. It matters because food matters (his physical health matters, the pleasure of eating matters), and because the stories that are served with food matter. These stories bind our family together, and bind our family to others.
At age 12, I stopped eating red meat. Before then I ate raw hamburger [you know, rolled up in a ball] and the chicken livers that my Nana cooked. At 18, I gave up all other meat. I ate fish off and on until a few years ago. Now I’m a non-dairy vegetarian. I’m not vegan because I cannot afford to be. It is a complex and complicated undertaking and can be very expensive. If Alicia Silverstone wants to come to my apartment with a personal chef, I’m more than happy to go vegan.
Eating Animals reads as a cross between a memoir and an investigative journalism expose on factory farming, the humane treatment of animals, and making wise choices in the food that you eat. In between the plethora of facts, Jonathan Safran Foer mixes in his own memories of food, his decisions to become a vegetarian, and his thoughts on the entire United States food industry. Eating Animals is an ambitious undertaking and Jonathan Safran Foer spent three years researching the book, interviewing all kinds of people and traveling throughout the United States in his quest for knowledge. He goes on a rescue mission to a turkey farm with an animal rights activist. He visited Paul Willis’s hog farm in Iowa and also “heritage” poultry farmer Frank Reese. He wanted to become an educated consumer. Safran Foer is clearly anti-factory farming. And honestly, who wouldn’t be? Is Eating Animals going to be a vegetarian manifesto for some? Sure. Many people will not pick up this book because they do not want to know about the food that they are putting in their mouths. I read a passage to my mother and she didn’t want to hear it. Ignorance is bliss, as the saying goes. If people go around not thinking that the food on their plate once roamed a verdant pasture or was crammed into a minute stall just so that they could have tender meat to eat, maybe they’d think twice.
This is why when fully conscious cattle at the (then) largest kosher slaughterhouse in the world, Agriprocessors in Postville, Iowa, were videotaped having their tracheas and esophagi systematically pulled from their cut throats, languishing for up to three minutes as a result of sloppy slaughter, and being shocked with electric prods in their faces, it bothered me even more than the innumerable times that I’d heard of such things happening at conventional slaughterhouses.
To my relief, much of the Jewish community spoke out against the Iowa plant.
Ultimately Eating Animals is for people to read who know little about our agricultural business and want a brisk, thoughtful, exhaustively researched book. It lacks preaching and serves to deliver the goods and let the reader debate the pros and cons of factory farming and food production and to purchase and consume food with a conscious state of mind. Do you know how that chicken got to your table? Did that lobster feel anything when it was thrown into a boiling pot of water? Is the slaughtering of cows as painless a process as the meat industry claims? The reader will find these answers in Eating Animals. If you’re at all squeamish and love your veal, lamb, foie gras, pate, juicy steak, hamburger and just plain old chicken, Eating Animals is not going to be a pleasant or palatable read for you. However, do not let that deter you. The wonderful, sensitive approach of Safran Foer eases the reader into each topic, one toe at a time. It’s an important topic. Along the way, you will also find out about Safran Foer’s own journey to vegetarianism. He writes with honesty, humor, and straightforward clarity.
I’ve restricted myself to mostly discussing how our food choices affect the ecology of our planet and the lives of its animals, but I could have just as easily made the entire book about public health, worker’s rights, decaying rural communities or global poverty—all of which are profoundly affected by factory farming. Factory farming, of course, does not cause all the world’s problems, but it is equally remarkable just how many of them intersect there. And it is equally remarkable, and completely improbable, that the likes of you and me would have real influence over factory farming. But no one can seriously doubt the influence of US consumers on global farm practices.
Let me share some of the highlights:
Ten million land animals are slaughtered for food every year in America [pg. 15]
Many scientists predict the total collapse of all fished species in less than fifty years—and intense efforts are underway to catch, kill, and eat even more sea animals. [pg.33]
Most male layers [chickens that lay eggs] are destroyed by being sucked through a series of pipes onto an electrified plate. [pg. 48]
Perhaps the quintessential example of bullshit, bycatch refers to sea creatures caught by accident—except not really “by accident,” since bycatch has been consciously built into contemporary fishing methods. . .The average shrimp trawling operation throws 80 to 90 percent of sea animals it captures overboard, dead or dying, as bycatch. [pg. 49]
A University of Chicago study recently found that our food choices contribute at least as much as our transportation choices to global warming. [pg. 58]
Fish build complex nests, form monogamous relationships, hunt cooperatively with other species and use tools. They recognize one another as individuals (and keep track of who is to be trusted and who is not). [pg. 65]
Killing chickens: The conveyer system drags the birds through an electrified water bath. This most likely paralyzes them but doesn’t render them insensible . . .The next stop on the line for the immobile-but-conscious bird will be an automated throat slitter [Netflix Food Inc. and it shows this clearly]. [pg. 133]
In 2004, a collection of the world’s experts on emerging zoonotic diseases gathered to discuss the possible relationship between all those compromised and sick farm animals, and pandemic explosions. [pg. 138]
In parts of the world where milk is not a staple of the diet, people often have less osteoporosis and fewer bone fractures than Americans do. The highest rates of osteoporosis are seen in countries where people consume the most dairy foods. [pg. 147]
Killing pigs: After getting stunned and hopefully rendered unconscious on the first, or at least the second, application of the stun gun, the pig is hung up by its feet and “stuck”—stabbed in the neck—and left to bleed out. [pg.155]
Conservative estimates by the EPA indicate that chicken, hog, and cattle excrement have already polluted 35,000 miles of rivers in twenty-two states (for reference, the circumference of the earth is roughly 25,000 miles). [pg. 179]
According to The Handbook of Salmon Farming: Six sources of suffering for salmon are: (1) water so fouled that it makes it hard to breathe; (2) crowding so intense that animals being to cannibalize one another; (3) handling so invasive that physiological measures of stress are evident a day later; (4) disturbance by farmworkers and wild animals; (5) nutritional deficiencies that weaken the immune system; and (6) the inability to form a stable social hierarchy, resulting in more cannibalism. [pg. 190]
Here’s a list of some famous vegetarians:
Alicia Silverstone Abbie Cornish
Portia de Rossi J.M. Coetzee
Benjamin Gibbard Zooey Deschanel
Alanis Morissette Shania Twain
Jim Carrey Pamela Anderson
Morrissey Dennis Rodman
Chris Martin Liv Tyler
Casey Affleck Kristen Bell
Chelsea Clinton Billie Joe Armstrong
Emily Deschanel Lisa Edelstein
Kevin Eubanks Traci Bingham
Natalie Portman Nastassja Kinski
Sir Paul McCartney Stella McCartney
Cilian Murphy Damon Albarn
Kate Bush Jane Goodall
Thom Yorke Julie Christie
–review by Amy Steele
Jonathan Safran Foer will be speaking as part of the Brookline Booksmith Reading series on November 11.
GREAT NEWS: HACHETTE BOOK GROUP is graciously providing me with THREE copies of Eating Animals to give away.
To Enter: Leave email in the comment section and if you dare, answer this question: are you a vegetarian or have you considered becoming a vegetarian? Why or Why not?
OPEN TO U.S. AND CANADIAN RESIDENTS ONLY. CONTEST ENDS DECEMBER 1ST.
Do you know where your food really comes from? Food Inc. director Robert Kenner wants you to know. He sets out across America to find the answers. He interviews Eric Schlosser, the author of Fast Food Nation and The Omnivore’s Dilemma author Michael Pollan. Food Inc. will open your eyes and mind, may break your heart, and will definitely churn your stomach at least once or twice.
According to Food Inc., Americans want food bigger, faster, fatter, and cheaper. Why not? Americans like big things: look at gas-guzzling SUVs on the roads; the popularity of venti iced lattes; and extra large portions of food. The average American eats 200 lbs. of meat a year. [Gross] Americans like fast things: everyone is constantly on a cell phone; IMing; Twittering; no one wants to wait in line; everything is now, now, now. And fatter? According to the CDC, 34% of adults and 17% of children [ages 6-17] are obese. One in three people born after 2000 will develop early onset diabetes. And of course everyone is looking for things that are cheaper. Organic lettuce is $4.00/head and a can of peas is $1.00? What are you going to buy?
There are 47,000 products available in a modern American supermarket. The image supermarkets use to sell food is of the farming industry or “Agrarian American” with messages of “farm fresh” or images of farms, cows, pastures, picket fences. When most of the eggs, milk, cheese, and meat sold in a supermarket are mass produced factory-style. In the film, Carole Morrison, Perdue “chicken farm” owner says: “This isn’t farming. This is just mass-production like an assembly line.” The average chicken farmer makes $18,000 a year, yet invests over $500,000. The food industry has become corporate run and not about the consumer.
The FDA and USDA have less control than before due to the influence of a few mega-corporations that run everything. In 2006, the FDA conducted only 9,164 food safety inspections. Companies place “profit ahead of consumer health.” Food is overly processed. Animals are corn fed. Farm-raised fish (salmon, tilapia, and tuna) are fed corn. The food we eat is not that healthy. There’s engineering of food. There’s less regulation. Some food may contain pesticides, hormones, or other synthetic additives that no one should be ingesting. Bacteria easily get into food products and inspection processes have become lapse. More often there are incidences of food-borne illnesses in the news.
E. coli and Salmonella outbreaks have become frequent in the U.S. In 2007, there were 73, 000 people sickened by E. coli. In the film is a devastating story of Barbara Kowalcyk’s son who died of an E. coli infection 12 days after eating hamburgers. The FDA recalled the meat 16 days after his death. She is now a food safety advocate.
As a vegetarian and someone who mostly shops at Whole Foods, watching this film was rather painful for me. I recognize that everyone has a choice even though I think meat is gross and vile. Watch those chickens being killed and immediately go out and eat some chicken and come back and leave a comment. The truth of the matter is though, how much do you want to and can you in actuality pay for food? The process to get organic food to be reasonably priced is going to take a long time. I often have to shop at three stores to get everything I need and, more importantly, can afford. When the cost of food is raised, people give up savings or spending on healthcare or education. [I also suggest you take the time to watch the stellar documentary King Corn]
Food Inc. is not an attack on farmers but on the loss of consumer rights and an expose on the big business model that has been bringing down food industry for decades. Sure, it is mostly one-sided. Kenner claims he had no “agenda” or preconceived notion going into the filming of this documentary but I don’t believe it. The message is clear: eat organic. Do see Food Inc. You may cringe a bit but the message is vital to the health of our nation.
I sat down to talk to Food Inc. director Robert Kenner earlier in the week.
Amy Steele [AS]: So what kind of audience are you looking to attract with this film?
Robert Kenner [RK]: I didn’t make this for the convinced. I’m not looking to preach to the choir. I’m really hoping to broaden the circle. I didn’t start out to make a film with a preconceived point of view. I really just wanted to do an examination of our food system. And I just thought it thought it would be interesting to talk to all sorts of different people who are involved unfortunately most of the ag [agriculture] industry did not want to talk to me, did not want us to know where our food is grown and what’s in it and that was for me the shock.
When I go to Sacramento to a hearing about cloned animals and that industry representative said, “I think it’s against the consumer’s interest to label this because it would only confuse them.” That gave me goose bumps. I’m thinking, “Wait a second. If you have a good product, aren’t you supposed to advertise it? Not try to hide it? Whether it’s GMOs [genetically modified organism] or RBSTs [growth hormones to get cows to produce more milk] for dairy cattle or Trans fats, the industry will go to great lengths to stop you from getting the information about what is in your food. Consumers have power to change what they are getting but we’re being denied the information. If we want to have a free market and freedom to choose things, it should be based on information. So I realize this is a film that goes beyond food. Ultimately this low cost food is costing way too much money.
AS: How do you get the people who will benefit most from seeing the film to see the film?
RK: First of all, all of us will benefit. The problem is we’re subsidizing food with food that is making us sick. Therefore there’s inexpensive food we can buy but we pay for it on a bunch of levels. We’re paying for it with our tax dollars to subsidize it. We’re paying for it with our healthcare dollars as well and it’s going to be a fortune. So even though the food is cheap when you go to the check out counter, it’s really very expensive.
AS: Apples can be $1 an apple.
RK: If we stop subsidizing unhealthy food it will help bring down the cost of good food and it will save us in health care. Here’s a fact for you. [writer’s note: I cannot find Kenner’s date of birth so I cannot do any “fact checking” here] When I was a kid, food cost us about 18% of our paychecks; today it cost us about 9%. Healthcare cost us about 5% and today it cost us about 18%. In aggregate, our costs have gone up and I think there’s a real direct relationship between healthcare and food. So we really have to fix the system and I thought the tobacco analogy was a good one. There are a few powerful corporations with unbelievable amounts of money, totally connected to government, who are putting out misleading information about the safety of these products. I think when we start to understand what this food does to us we’re going to change the system. So I’m very optimistic. It is going to change even though we’re up against incredibly powerful forces. The consumers are also more powerful than they are. And that was one of the empowering things that you learned. You get to vote three times a day. But we also have to vote with our dollars to make it an even playing field. So how to we get the food to Baldwin Park and places like that in the movie. That’s the challenge but I think that’s also with our votes. I think we have to create a fair system.
AS: So. The patented genes with Monsanto. Can you explain that a bit more? Are they the only company that makes soy beans?
RK: Monsanto is amazing. They’re a company that practiced radiation on animals in the 40s and 50s. They invented Agent Orange in the 60s and 70s and now they’re the ones who provide us our food. They are looking to own seeds that they can use their chemicals on. They are looking for ways of selling fertilizer.
AS: But there are people who do soybeans without their seeds?
RK: Very few.
AS: [thinking. great the majority of the protein in my diet. Good thing I love quinoa]
RK: And they’re putting people out of business who don’t use theirs and that’s the problem. They’ve gained control. They own our food. This is all about anti-trust. How could this go on in our country? I’m so amazed.
AS: Even when you went to that organic market and that guy was pointing out that Kashii is owned by Kellogg and…
RK: It’s all a consolidated system. A lot of people feed into it but there’s a bottle neck because there are very few corporations that control it.
AS: So even with the USDA and FDA, they’ve lost control and the corporations have more control of the food industry?
RK: Well there’s that woman whose son died of eating a hamburger. The horrible part was the meat that they knew had killed her son stayed on the shelf for 16 days after he died because the USDA did not have the power to recall that meat. I didn’t know that.
AS: I actually took a class in infectious diseases and it was interesting. Every week the professor had new articles and new things going on with food-borne illnesses when we discussed them.
RK: It’s constant. You think with science it should have gotten but it’s getting worse and that’s the scary part but I’m optimistic and I do believe that we’re going to change. I do believe that food safety laws are going to be one of the first things to change. The FDA will be able to gain control to be able to recall but the USDA recalls meat. The laws are so byzantine and none of them have power but it looks like it’s changing.
AS: How can the average consumer make the changes and get her voice heard?
RK: First of all, shop at Farmer’s Markets whenever possible. Try to buy organic whenever possible. Try to buy local. But when you go to the supermarket, read labels. All those weird words for corn and soy, they are there to make us sick. Ask questions. Let people know we care. It’s going to change things. If you start asking question, start making changes, it’s going to affect that system. It’ll bring the cost down. As we increase the demand for this, it’ll improve the distribution systems.
AS: What are the biggest issues affecting the food industry?
RK: Well for me it was connecting the dots. The food system’s become industrialized. Corn and soy has become subsidized. The corn and soy is making us sick. One in three Americans is going to get diabetes and it’s going to bankrupt healthcare. We’re not allowed to know what’s in our food. Upton Sinclair in The Jungle wrote about a system that is broken and we kept improving the system but then it got worse and worse again. We use illegal immigrants. Think about a society using people who have no rights grow and process their food. There’s something wrong with that. Not only do we treat the animals badly, we treat the workers badly, and we treat the earth just as badly. And we the consumers are treated badly. So it’s broken.
AS: Why should people care about this film?
RK: Because we eat this stuff everyday. We should know what’s in the food. We’re not telling you what to eat but we’re telling you that you should have the right to know what you eat.